If you are a collector like me, you’ll understand how important it is to find the rarest Stanley Cup colors.
Recently, I have been obsessed with the Tiffany Blue Starbucks x Stanley Quencher. All I could think about was adding that specific color to my collection.
I’d constantly check online and Facebook shops, coming up empty-handed. Feeling defeated, I ordered the Nectarine instead. But then, fate intervened!
Yesterday afternoon, I was venting to one of my trusty sellers about the constant unavailability of the Tiffany Blue. To my surprise, she called me back not even a minute later, her voice filled with excitement. She contacted another seller, and he had two available for purchase. Without hesitation, she snagged one for me.
I was extremely grateful. While I paid a lot of money for it, adding this color to my collection made me happy.
If you are looking for Stanley cup rarest colors, this top eight list will give you an idea of them. However, the company is always adding different colors, so this list may not be definitive.
1. Scoville Aubergine
The rarity of a Stanley Cup color depends on many factors. One is that it has not been released yet. The company is rumored to release three new colors in the Philippines on May 20th.
That means no one has purchased any of these colors yet, making it one of the rarest colors to date.
Other colors include Mustard Win and Scoville Lime Green.
2. Starbucks Tiffany Blue Collab
Do you know the seller’s resale price for a Tiffany Blue Stanley cup? I have paid over 300 for one to add to my collection.
Because it is only available in the Philippines, it is one of the most expensive and sought-after Stanley tumblers.
I understand why, images do not do this tumbler justice. It is very beautiful.
3. Watermelon Moonshine
This color is cute but it isn’t one of my favorites. However, my friends say it is one of the hardest colors to find.
The tumbler wasn’t part of the company’s standard color releases since it was created in collaboration with country music star Lainey Wilson.
Thus, making it a unique design not widely available.
4. Winter Pink X Starbucks
The Starbucks x Stanley Quencher in “Winter Pink” is one of the most popular and rarest Stanley out.
This Target-exclusive quickly gained a reputation as one of the most expensive resales tumblers. The lines in January 2024 for this cup were long. I have seen videos of the frenzy inside Target. It was brutal.
Unfortunately, I do not have this in my collection as of yet.
5. Stanley Copper/Magnolia Cream
The Magnolia Cream or Copper is one of the most minimalistic colors to date.
Plus, it is the easiest to decorate with accessories. Again, like many rare Stanley the resale value is between $300-$450
Yikes.
6. HAMMERTON
While Hammertone is not that rare, it is still on my list. The vintage Stanley Hammertone products, especially unique colors, hold the most collectible value.
It is not as pricey as Winter Pink X Starbucks but it isn’t the price you’ll get online at Stanely 1913.
7. Starbucks x Stanley Holiday “Cherry Red”
Another collaboration with limited availability.
This festive red Quencher was only around for the 2023 holidays, making it a seasonal treasure many missed out on.
I am proud to say that I have one in my collection.
8.AntiSocial SocialClub x Stanley
I am a fan, but I have not gotten my hands on one yet.
This unique collaboration with a streetwear brand offered a limited number of white Quenchers.
The exclusivity and trendy collab design make this a rare find for Stanley collectors.
Wrapping Up
It is one of the best feelings when you can buy a rare Stanley tumbler. I feel a sense of achievement and excitement to dress up my cup.
My top eight list came from trusty sellers. To determine the rarety, they look at the resale value, the difficulties they experience when finding them, and if it is a limited edition collab.
As of the 20th of May, the Mustard Win, Scoville Lime Green, and Scoville Aubergine will remain the rarest for 2024.
At least that’s what I predicted.